April 26, 2009
VOL 26 NO 17
Advertise here
Acts of God are no longer the worst nightmare for insurers
Biggest risk to the industry is now said to be investment performance, writes Jon Ihle

Just a year ago, the top concerns of insurance companies were too much regulation and natural catastrophes. Executives believed that the biggest risks facing their industry stemmed from unpredictable acts of God and heavy-handed government interference in the free market.


In the meantime the sector has learned – by watching the spectacular failures of their colleagues in banking – about the dangers of manmade disasters and light-touch regulation.


A report by PWC and the UK's Centre for the Study of Financial Innovation published early this month – 'Insurance Banana Skins 2009' – found that this year insurers are most worried about investment performance and capital availability. These issues did not even crack the top 10 in 2008's survey, but are crucial in the midst of economic crisis.


As the report's summary points out, insurance companies depend on investments to pay claims, stay profitable and protect their capital reserves. Premium income is not enough to cover these commitments, especially as claims tend to rise in recessions while both new and repeat business falls off. So the industry is forced to lean more on stock market investments to bridge the gap, but the markets are in the middle of the deepest crisis since the Great Depression and returns are extremely volatile.


The resulting squeeze on profitability threatens the solvency of insurance companies, which is why they are suddenly so focused on capital availability. And as any banker could tell you, capital is pretty hard to find out there.


The ratings agencies have taken note of the situation. This month alone, Standard & Poor's cut Aviva's credit rating and put Zurich and Axa Ireland on negative watch. Nothing dramatic, nothing to panic about, but the analysis is telling.


"Amid a daunting financial landscape, [insurers'] ability to raise capital is more restricted than would previously have been the case," S&P said in a research report. In a separate note, the agency was more specific about Axa Ireland, where shareholders' equity has been cut in half because of huge falls in the value of equities the company holds, predicting further weakening of its capital position due to weakness in investment markets.


What's happening here? Are insurance companies – supposedly the experts in pricing and managing risk – heading the same way as banks?


Well, not so fast. Some industry observers dismiss the recent downgrades as merely a sign that the ratings agencies are acting tough after badly misjudging the risks associated with subprime mortgage-backed securities and watching much of the financial sector go down in flames as a result.


But the dangers facing the insurance sector have grown and become more serious because of the economic crisis. For life companies, poor investment performance is proving a real challenge as customers turn away from savings products that are producing dire returns, in turn reducing fee income. Companies that came to depend on investment income during the boom have a big hole to fill.


For general insurers focused on motor, home and commercial products, the loss of contributions to investment returns means there is less money to protect reserves. This is why Irish consumers are experiencing higher premium costs even though prices in general are coming down in other parts of the economy.


The danger here, according to industry analysts, is that some companies might be tempted to underprice for risk and hope to plug the hole with now-unreliable investment income.


"If someone tries to cashflow out of the pricing cycle they could get into real trouble," said Garvan O'Neill, insurance partner with PWC Ireland.


The deeper the downgrades go, the more expensive financing becomes and the more tempting it is to try this trick. And without the central bank lines of credit available the way they are for banks, insurers could find themselves more isolated if liquidity becomes a problem.


According to a source at a major Irish insurer, the risk will be at its greatest two years after growth slows – in other words, this year.


According to figures from the Irish Insurance Federation, most non-life business has been written at a loss since 2007. During a period of rapid growth, income – even on business written at a loss – can cover claims because policy-holders prefer to keep their no-claims bonuses intact. But as economic and business growth slows and claims catch up, the insurer has to release reserves to meet commitments. If investment income does not compensate, the company eats into its capital and risks insolvency. It's not unlike the situation Irish banks got into by lending with the expectation of continuing property price appreciation.


Not coincidentally, since the banking crisis erupted last September, regulators have moved to ensure the stability of the insurance industry. The Financial Regulator already required insurance companies to keep a buffer of 50% above the minimum solvency margin required by EU regulations. But late last year the regulator instituted a new electronic reporting system to monitor financial performance and demanded quarterly – rather than annual – returns.


At the same time, the regulator conducted a survey of insurance companies to get a sense of their solvency positions and asset distribution. While there has been a downward trend in solvency generally in the sector, the regulator told the Sunday Tribune its is still "monitoring closely the solvency position and compliance with prudential requirements of all companies under our supervision and, in general, is satisfied that companies remain well capitalised."


Acting chief executive Mary O'Dea has her hands full with the banking crisis, but the regulator has beefed up its insurance division recently by appointing a former Hibernian executive as deputy head in an effort to get more practitioners involved in supervision.


The big change in the industry, however, is coming with the so-called Solvency II regime, which was passed by the European Parliament last week. Solvency II will force insurers to set their capital according to the risk levels in the policies they underwrite, rather than according to the premiums they collect. The changes are expected to eliminate some of the dangers of underpricing by removing the incentive to discount risky business for the sake of cash flow.


The new rules take effect in 2012 and promise to bring with them sweeping changes to the structure of companies and the industry as a whole. But as we've seen with banking, a lot can change in just one year, let alone three.


April 26, 2009

Post a comment

(Required, published)
(Required, not published)
(Optional)

Comments are moderated by our editors, so there may be a delay between submission and publication of your comment. Offensive or abusive comments will not be published. Please note that your IP address (67.202.55.193) will be logged to prevent abuse of this feature. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions

Also in News

Sunday Tribune
January 30, 2011
VOL 28 NO 5
Advertise here

Following a review by the Receiver, in consultation with the management of the company, of the financial and risk areas of the Sunday Tribune it has been decided that publication of the newspaper together with ... more

Where's Enda Kenny?
Devils' Owen and old heads sends lively ...
Words and pictures
Businesses learn the true cost of being ...
The truth about Fintan O’Toole’s ...
A new political movement packed with household names and fronted by David McWilliams, Eamon Dunphy, Shane Ross and Fintan O ... more
Where’s Enda Kenny?
FOR those arguing the case that Fine Gael is deliberately adopting a tactic of maintaining a low profile for its ... more
Drug dealer Tony Felloni freed ...
NOTORIOUS drug trafficker Tony Felloni was released from Mountjoy prison yesterday, having served 15 ... more
Dunphy backs RTÉ employees ...
Broadcaster and pundit Eamon Dunphy has rowed in behind RTé staff angry over the "disproportionate" salaries of ... more
Devils’ Owen and old heads ...
It took the old heads of Ryan Giggs and Michael Owen to overcome a spritely Southampton as Manchester ... more
English Rose ready to bloom
Like an increasingly ratty teacher during the big snow, the more time we spend going through the names that ... more
Brosnan steps back so he ...
Over the Christmas while Down Under with the family, Eoin Brosnan caught up with Tommy Walsh in Melbourne ... more
Malachy Clerkin - One sport ...
Two cases, two sports, two very different ways of looking at the world. On Friday in Mallorca, Spanish ... more
Words and pictures
How would it be if instead of our natural life span being around 80 years or so, it was 30 at most ... more
Plan of action
His hit soul album The Defamation of Strickland Banks is still in the Irish top 20 nearly 10 months after ... more
Under the skin
They called themselves "The Clan" and "The Summit". The press termed them "The Rat Pack ... more
Radio Critic, Eithne Tynan - ...
Yippee, fundamentalists are back on the radio. Showing brazen disregard for one of the twin ... more
Blanket bank guarantee was to ...
The banking guarantee, which has cost the taxpayer €46bn so far, was originally intended to allow the Central Bank to provide emergency funding to the collapsing financial sector without it being noticed by the ECB or ... more
Businesses learn the true cost ...
Last week the ESB discovered what a lot of Irish firms have been experiencing in the harsh world of the ... more
Top economist forecasts new rate ...
Ireland could get a second, much bigger interest rate reduction on the €22.5bn it has borrowed ... more
Will Greencore have the stomach ...
Greencore shareholders will be in less than celebratory mood at the company's annual general ... more
Crystal-clear vision emerges from the ...
Confidence is key to its success. Hesitancy, or indecision, can result in failure. We're not talking about ... more
Three To View
No 8 West Terrace, Inchicore, Dublin 8
Asking price: €275,000
Floor area: 72sq m (775sq ft ... more
Choose life on the boardwalk
Right now, courtesy of Martin Scorsese and a writer/producer who worked on The Sopranos, Kelly Macdonald ... more
The Prada-wearing devil is in ...
As the CAO deadline looms and parents discuss with their children the order in which their courses should ... more
Eyes in the storm
Conor Faughnan, Policy Director with AA Roadwatch
'At the height of the snow, five people were ... more
Instant Parma
The first time I tasted parma ham was in one of those old-fashioned little trattorias that have man-sized ... more

Comments

  1. antony February 3, 2011 at 5:07 a.m.

    D4 Irish Pub and cafe [great grub ] EAST ...

  2. phil February 2, 2011 at 5:23 p.m.

    God bless ya antony,I'm gonna miss ya.If I happened ...

  3. Daragh February 2, 2011 at 10:29 a.m.

    Thanks for all the great pieces over the years. ...

  4. Jerry February 2, 2011 at 1:48 a.m.

    All great men to comment, but when the chips ...

  5. antony February 2, 2011 at 1:44 a.m.

    I think thats great news. Yere geting a new ...

  6. Richard February 2, 2011 at 1:02 a.m.

    Stop building roads; it facilitates environmentally and socially hazardous ...

  7. antony February 2, 2011 at 12:58 a.m.

    STOP PAYING .Are ye so full of fear that ...

  8. Frank February 2, 2011 at 12:37 a.m.

    Best of luck to all in the Trib. Worked ...

  9. antony February 2, 2011 at 12:22 a.m.

    Nobody has any money to invest HOPE, and the ...

  10. gayle killilea February 2, 2011 at 12:06 a.m.

    Best of luck to all of the Sunday Tribune ...

Search



RSS Feeds

RSS Feeds

Subscribe to The Sunday Tribune’s RSS feeds. Learn more.


Advertise here
Click to create

Get off to a profitable sports betting start today at sportsbetting.co.uk

Website by Maithú™

Share this article

Search



RSS Feeds

RSS Feeds

Subscribe to The Sunday Tribune’s RSS feeds. Learn more.


Advertise here
Click to create
Website by Maithú™