Eight TDs and senators queried on overclaiming expenses

Claims for overnights while abroad and excessive mileage questioned by Oireachtas committee.

Public Affairs Correspondent Ken Foxe reports

Frank Fahey: claimed for nine overnights at €1,260 while abroad

Keaveney: contacted three times on expenses

Ferris: put in for 108 one-way journeys

Lowry: claim query on overnights

Enda Kenny: claimed too many overnights

Michael D'Arcy: claimed while abroad

Timmins: claimed for meetings he didn't go to

John Cregan: contacted twice about expenses

AT least eight TDs and senators have been contacted by the Houses of the Oireachtas after making overclaims on their expenses.

The politicians were told they had asked for too much to cover the cost of overnight or mileage expenses, an investigation by the Sunday Tribune can reveal.

Former minister Frank Fahey was contacted on five separate occasions about his expenses, where claims were deemed to have been too high.

Other TDs and senators contacted include Fianna Fáil senator Cecelia Keaveney, Sinn Féin TD Martin Ferris, independent TD Michael Lowry and the Fine Gael leader Enda Kenny.

The eight politicians do not include senators Ivor Callely, Larry Butler and Ann Ormonde, whose expenses claims have already been the subject of scrutiny.

In June 2008, Frank Fahey over-claimed for nine 'overnights' – which would have been worth an estimated €1,260 – while he was abroad on official business.

The Houses of the Oireachtas told him: "You sought recoupment of 45 overnights for attendance at sittings of Dáil Éireann.

"However, our records indicate that during the above period, you had been part of the IPU Assembly that visited Capetown on 9 April 2008 to 19 April 2008 and you had also been part of the COE Delegation to Stockholm on 14 to 16 May 2008.

"Unfortunately, you would not be entitled to be recouped for nine overnights during this period."

Fahey reached quota

In September of last year, claims for six overnights were refused because Fahey had reached his quota of nights or had not given sufficient details about them. In March 2008, Fahey – who claimed upwards of €75,000 a year under the old expenses system – was also contacted about a small overclaim of one night, where he had already put in for the maximum.

On two other occasions – in October and November 2007 – the former minister was contacted about small discrepancies, both of which resulted in non-payment for a single night.

The Fianna Fáil Senator Cecelia Keaveney was contacted three times about her expenses, documents obtained under the Freedom of Information Act have shown.

In a claim for several months in 2008, the Donegal politician put in for 33 'overnights' despite having been abroad several times during the same period.

A letter sent to her in July 2008 said: "You sought recoupment of 33 overnights for attendance at sittings of Seanad Éireann.

"However, our records indicate that within the above period you had visited Paris on 20 May 2008… Belfast on 22 May 2008… and Strasbourg between 23-26 June 2008.

"Therefore [we are] unable to recoup the eight overnights for Seanad sittings for these dates as they fall within the above-mentioned trips abroad."

Six months later, Keaveney was again contacted about claiming the "overnight" allowance of €140 per night when abroad.

This time, the senator had been in Istanbul with the Council of Europe for four nights and payment for a single night was not made.

Keaveney – who claimed up to €59,000 annually under the old Senate expense system – was also contacted a third time by the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission after making a claim for five committee meetings.

Independent TD Michael Lowry, who recently said he could no longer afford to cover his legal costs at the Moriarty tribunal, was also contacted about over-claiming.

In July 2009, the Houses of the Oireachtas wrote to him querying a claim for "overnights" which would have resulted in overpayment of €560.

The letter said: "In this application, you sought recoupment of 12 overnights for attendance at sittings in Dáil Eireann. However, our records indicate that the maximum number of overnights that can be recouped by you in respect of the above period is eight."

Sinn Féin TD Martin Ferris was among at least eight politicians to be contacted after he overclaimed for overnights and for mileage.

In one expense claim covering six months, he put in for 108 one-way journeys from Co Kerry and 65 overnights. The Houses of the Oireachtas contacted him to say that the maximum he could claim would be 95 trips and 59 stays in Dublin.

Letter to Enda Kenny

A letter sent to the Fine Gael leader Enda Kenny in March 2009 also explained how he had claimed too many "overnights" in one application.

Also contacted was Fine Gael's Michael D'Arcy, who inadvertently claimed for an overnight when he was abroad in Budapest, the Houses of the Oireachtas said.

Fine Gael TD Billy Timmins was also contacted twice about his claims.

In one letter, Timmins was told he had claimed for four overnights for attending committee meetings. However, inquiries by the Houses of the Oireachtas showed he had not been there for one of the meetings and two overnights were cancelled from his expense claim.

The Fianna Fáil TD John Cregan was contacted twice about his expenses, once where he claimed an overnight for Dáil business and a committee meeting that took place on the same day, and a second time where he had been abroad.

November 14, 2010

Comments

#1 noel kenneally commented, on November 14, 2010 at 7:46 p.m.:

no elected representative should get overnight or any other expenses unless they are legitimate & vouched for, do they realise the money required to pay their expenses, has to be borrowed & paid back by the taxpayer, people they puport to represent

#2 Ben O'Sullivan commented, on November 14, 2010 at 8:24 p.m.:

Pigs and Troughs come to mind!!

#3 seamus commented, on November 14, 2010 at 10:06 p.m.:

It seems a lot of them suffer from memory loss also- claiming for overnight allowance while they were abroad.

#4 Caitriona commented, on November 14, 2010 at 11:19 p.m.:

Hope this is greed is addressed in mother of all budgets in Dec.

#5 marguerite commented, on November 15, 2010 at 9:51 a.m.:

When will this dreadful government do one honourable thing for the Irish people. Call an election, make sure you vote them out, remember you get the government you vote for.

Make sure the next 'lot' are held accountable. Good luck to you all during this dreadful time, from your friends in Australia.
Yes, we know how lucky we are here.

#6 jack meyhoffer commented, on November 15, 2010 at 1:12 p.m.:

OINK, OINK, OINK!!!!!Its the only language they understand!!

#7 sean mcphillips commented, on November 15, 2010 at 6:49 p.m.:

You are who you vote for. Is it any wonder the country is up to its neck in debt with the calibre of miscreants who now 'run' the country and the other Fine-Agelers waiting in the wings.God help Ireland for these corrupt bastards won't.

#8 jack meskill commented, on November 19, 2010 at 10:24 a.m.:

In another country, these guys would face criminal proceedings. Not here. This absence of legal controls and the very different legal standards applied to the crimes of these "upper castes", as opposed to the immediate arrest and inevitable public humiliation and incarceration of a beggar stealing bread from a supermarket, is one of the main reasons foreign investors will not touch us again for many many years, after this IMF take-over. Why? because we are a nation of grubby schemers who accept that the rich should be allowed to get away with murder.
How many of those mentioned here have had their massive gambling losses on international property deals written off against tax payers and old age pensioners money? Is this what patriotism really means, being happy to let the rish few rip off the rest, with no loss of face, cash or perks???
Why is no-one demanding an immediate public declaration from every politician in dail or senate about their or their family or close friends' NAMA bail-outs, their preferential treatment by the banks or the jobs arranged for sons and daughters in tacit return for voting in the interest of bankers, builders, speculators or quite simply, themselves??

#9 jack meskill commented, on November 20, 2010 at 8:50 a.m.:

Please look at this film clip of the performance of one of these TDs at an important dail committee and think about what we need to do to clean up politics in Ireland;
http://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showth...

#10 jack meskill commented, on November 20, 2010 at 9:02 a.m.:

Maybe we should be worried for these poor guys?
After all, they may have property worries ?
For instance, look at this public information, available at "
http://www.oireachtas.ie/documents/p.... being Frank Fahey's published list of declared interests to the Dail, ;
"(1) 2 apts Castlerea, Co. Roscommon: letting; (2) Apartment 8A, 16 Eglinton Court, Galway: letting; (3) House at Kilbeacanty, Gort: letting; (4) Apartment at Dun Aengus, New Docks, Galway: letting; (5) House at Dun na Coirribe, Galway: letting; (6) House at Liscannor, Co. Clare: letting; (7) House at Rinawade Close, Leixlip: letting; (8) Shareholding in apartment at Dun na Coirribe, Galway; (9) Shareholding in extended family owned properties at Moydrum, Athlone: letting; (10) Shareholding 4 Apts & Shop, Lower Gerald Street, Limerick: letting; (11) Shareholding in Sage Construction Co. Ltd.; (12) Shareholding in retail unit, two offices and warehouse at Crowe Street, Gort; (13) House at Jumeirah Estates, Dubai; (14) Dwelling house at The Grove, Crowe Street; (15) Shareholding in apartment at Starthmore Road and one apartment at Tappan Street, Boston, Massachusetts: shareholding in Fahey Higgins L.L.C. Boston; (16) Five apartments owned in partnership at Rue Paul-Emile, Janson 1000, ten apartments owned in partnership at Rue Du Sceptre 1015, Brussels; (17) Apartment at Chancery Lane, Dublin 2; (18) Apartment at Cathedral Place, Limerick: letting; (19) House and site at Villefranche, France; (20) Deposit paid and contract signed on property at Porto De Mos, deposit paid at Lagos and Mongadoha Lameira, Alcantarilha, Portugal; (21) Apartment at Irishtown, Dublin. "

#11 phil commented, on November 20, 2010 at 8:25 p.m.:

Jack,your gonna give yourself a heart attack!!

#12 joe commented, on November 21, 2010 at 5:37 a.m.:

Frank Fahey is a lovely man with lovely hair and a lovely voice.

#13 On the road to god knows where commented, on November 21, 2010 at 11:40 a.m.:

Com'on Donegal, . Our future depends on you!!

#14 jack meskill commented, on November 21, 2010 at 5:30 p.m.:

I know, Phil, I know...........
I want to kidnap Drumm and Fitzie and torture them with a pliers and a blow torch in some cave in Connemara, until they give me the codes and tell me where they hid the money and then spill the beans on tape about all the dirty little deals done with all the dirty little politicians.........
Gawd help me........my blood pressure is 168 over 96 and rising.................