Last Saturday marked the tenth anniversary of England’s disappointing Euro 2016 defeat to Iceland. Kolbeinn Sigthórsson’s decisive goal slipped past Joe Hart, while Wayne Rooney struggled in midfield, and Harry Kane’s corners failed to inspire. In the aftermath, Roy Hodgson delivered a somber farewell at the press conference, a moment that feels almost surreal now.
Before Gareth Southgate took charge, expectations for the national team were at an all-time low. Southgate’s leadership transformed the squad, culminating in a historic penalty shootout victory against Colombia in the last 16 of the 2018 World Cup, their first knockout win in over a decade.
Thomas Tuchel’s task is markedly different. Following Southgate’s resignation after England’s loss in the Euro 2024 final, the Football Association sought an elite coach to navigate the next chapter. Data analysis played a crucial role in selecting Tuchel, as evidence suggested he could enhance England’s performance in high-stakes matches.
As England aims to secure their second star on the World Cup shirt, Tuchel faces immediate challenges. While they topped Group L, their path was not without obstacles, and the remarkable comeback against Croatia in Dallas remains unmatched. With Jude Bellingham and Kane excelling in attack, multiple areas of the team require attention, especially with the looming match against the Democratic Republic of the Congo in the last 32 on Wednesday.
A misstep in Atlanta could jeopardize Tuchel’s tenure. Historically, England has never lost to an African nation in World Cup play, and a mere last-16 appearance after defeating the DRC will not be celebrated.
Tuchel is acutely aware of the raised expectations. Following England’s 2-0 victory over Panama, he noted the reaction was somewhat subdued.
However, Tuchel embraces the heightened expectations. This is where he thrives. He reflected on the significance of having three players from the Iceland match—Kane, Jordan Henderson, and John Stones—still in the fold, stating,
“You will not find great athletes who didn’t suffer big defeats,”
He cited a recent Netflix documentary on Rafael Nadal, revealing the struggles behind the success.
“I thought he just wins every match out there every year,” Tuchel remarked. “But you see, wow, a year of injuries, a heavy loss there, another big defeat, doubts, sleepless nights. Even if you have scars, it is just the way it is. We all had our losses. Ask me how I felt after our 1-0 against New Zealand. I still remember thinking: ‘Am I good enough, am I good enough? Did I get this right? OK, let’s keep on.’”
Tuchel’s self-expectations are immense. The recent friendly against New Zealand was essentially a training session, yet he left contemplating his performance.
Excellence requires relentless pursuit. Tuchel boasts an impressive knockout win ratio of 74%. He guided Chelsea to Champions League victory in 2021 and reached three domestic cup finals, with additional triumphs at Borussia Dortmund and Paris Saint-Germain. This is where he excels.
“I tell you a funny story,” he expressed, though he tempered this enthusiasm with caution. Following a lackluster draw against Ghana, he anticipates encountering another defensive setup from the DRC. Patience will be essential, particularly since the DRC managed to secure a draw against Portugal in the group stages. Their strategy will likely focus on frustrating England and capitalizing on any defensive vulnerabilities.
Tuchel faces an injury crisis in the right-back position, with Reece James sidelined and Jarell Quansah nursing an ankle issue. He must also consider the fitness of Bukayo Saka, who has been dealing with an Achilles problem, before the potential last-16 match in Mexico City. One option is to prioritize Saka’s recovery by starting Noni Madueke instead. Alternatively, quick advancement is essential.
England possesses the talent necessary for success. However, they must display conviction. On the left flank, Marcus Rashford must refine his finishing skills if he continues to keep Anthony Gordon on the bench. Declan Rice will return to partner Elliot Anderson after being rested against Panama, although both midfielders have been managing muscular issues.
The match could evolve into a drawn-out affair, possibly leading to penalties. Tuchel’s shootout history has been inconsistent.
“My first cup final in Germany with Dortmund in my first year, I play against Bayern and against Pep [Guardiola]. It was a nightmare because Bayern and Pep, from 120 possible points they had 130 in the season or something. It was a joke. “We had the next highest number of points and were second. We prepared everything in this match. We needed to twist the tactics, and they twisted the tactics, and we twisted the structure and he twisted the structure. People got tired and it went into extra time. “Then the whistle went and I was just not prepared. I forgot to prepare for a penalty shootout. We ended up asking the players: ‘Do you want to shoot? Do you want to shoot?’ They were ready for it. “And we were absolutely not ready. We lost. A very painful experience and a big, big scar on me. I felt I had let myself down. It was the first time. It will never happen again. From there we started our own programme, our own preparation. “Now I go into the FA and I have on the highest level a penalty programme. We trained it. We have a process in place. We are prepared. This has become a very special part of football now. “We know exactly what is going to happen. This is still no guarantee that you win it. I had crazy penalty shootouts. Now it is on the highest level, thanks to the FA, of course, and thanks to my development. It is just another example that you sometimes have to have a painful experience to understand where to get better.” he recounted. “My first cup final in Germany with Dortmund in my first year, I play against Bayern and against Pep [Guardiola]. It was a nightmare because Bayern and Pep, from 120 possible points they had 130 in the season or something. It was a joke.”
“We had the next highest number of points and were second. We prepared everything in this match. We needed to twist the tactics, and they twisted the tactics, and we twisted the structure and he twisted the structure. People got tired and it went into extra time.”
“Then the whistle went and I was just not prepared. I forgot to prepare for a penalty shootout. We ended up asking the players: ‘Do you want to shoot? Do you want to shoot?’ They were ready for it. And we were absolutely not ready. We lost. A very painful experience and a big, big scar on me. I felt I had let myself down. It was the first time. It will never happen again. From there we started our own programme, our own preparation.”
“Now I go into the FA and I have on the highest level a penalty programme. We trained it. We have a process in place. We are prepared. This has become a very special part of football now. We know exactly what is going to happen. This is still no guarantee that you win it. I had crazy penalty shootouts. Now it is on the highest level, thanks to the FA, of course, and thanks to my development. It is just another example that you sometimes have to have a painful experience to understand where to get better.”
A decade later, England hopes to avoid any echoes of the past against Iceland.
- World Cup 2026
- Thomas Tuchel
- England
- Democratic Republic of the Congo football team
- World Cup
- features
