Germany’s World Cup journey ended in Boston not with a quiet departure, but rather an intense struggle against a resolute Paraguay, culminating in a dramatic penalty shootout.
This defeat marked Germany’s first loss in a shootout since the iconic Panenka in 1976, characterized by a series of mistakes and missed opportunities, leading to what can only be described as a sporting collapse as twilight descended in New England. Paraguay now moves on to face a last-16 match in Philadelphia, celebrating what is arguably the pinnacle of their footballing achievements, following a display of remarkable determination and defensive prowess.
For coach Julian Nagelsmann, this loss signals a potential turning point. This isn’t the powerhouse Germany of the past, yet they possess more quality than what was displayed. Jürgen Klopp, observing from a distance, has expressed both critique and sympathy for Nagelsmann, hinting at a desire to take the reins himself—perhaps an opportunity is on the horizon for him.
The Boston Stadium, a picturesque venue, provided a fitting backdrop with its sprawling green campus and a sense of timeless grandeur. It was filled to capacity as the match kicked off, bathed in the harsh afternoon sun, creating an impressive sight.
The match began energetically, with the first signs of excitement manifesting just six minutes in as the crowd initiated a Mexican wave.
By halftime, Paraguay had executed a nearly flawless first half, much to Germany’s confusion as they trudged off the pitch. Despite holding 79% possession and completing 308 passes compared to Paraguay’s 55, they were down 1-0 and struggling against an impenetrable Paraguayan defense.
This was Germany’s first knockout match in the World Cup since their triumph in Brazil in 2014. Following a lackluster performance against Ecuador in the group stage, there was pressure on Nagelsmann to reposition Joshua Kimmich into midfield. However, he maintained the same central framework, only making one change by introducing Denis Undav as a more dynamic No. 10.
Gustavo Alfaro, Paraguay’s head coach, is a seasoned 63-year-old Argentine known for his deep commitment to a defensive playing style. He has also emphasized the sport’s role in advocating for the underprivileged and opposing FIFA’s practices.
From the outset, Paraguay’s strategy was evident: Germany appeared to be moving laterally against a well-organized Paraguayan 4-5-1 formation. This formation proved fluid, occasionally morphing into a 4-6-0 setup, leaving Germany with little room to maneuver. The game became so lethargic that the hydration break felt like a welcome interruption, marking a highlight in what was otherwise a stifling matchup.
After 27 minutes, Antonio Rüdiger, frustrated with the lack of creativity, opted for a long clearance that sailed over the heads of the players, resulting in a goal kick, a moment that underscored his team’s struggles.
Then, out of the blue, Paraguay struck. Their timely goal was a testament to their pressure and urgency. Julio Enciso, standing at just 5ft 6in, scored with a powerful header, showcasing his determination. The play was expertly constructed, with Manuel Neuer initially punching clear a corner from Miguel Almirón, only for the ball to be returned to Enciso, who cleverly assisted Matías Galarza for a swift cross, perfectly placed for Enciso’s finish.
Germany made a substitution at halftime, bringing on Leon Goretzka for Felix Nmecha, which seemed to invigorate their midfield. However, Enciso almost doubled the lead shortly after, intercepting a poor back-pass from Kimmich, but his shot was denied by Neuer.
The equalizer came for Germany in the 54th minute through a different approach. Florian Wirtz made a well-timed run to the left before delivering a precise diagonal cross, which Kai Havertz met with an elegant flicked header into the net. This goal raised hopes for Germany’s revival.
As the game progressed, Jamal Musiala replaced Undav, who had largely gone unnoticed throughout the match, a testament to his limited impact in such a crowded field.
However, the game soon reverted to its cautious rhythm, with a burst of activity occurring in the 75th minute as Wirtz and Havertz combined again, only for Orlando Gill to make a crucial save.
With two minutes left in regular time, Nagelsmann introduced fresh legs in the form of Nick Woltemade, who struggled to make a significant impact during those final moments.
As the sun set over the pitch, extra time commenced, bringing with it a sense of inevitability. Germany continued to dominate possession and create chances, with Woltemade missing a close-range opportunity and seeing another shot blocked.
Paraguay, now retreating deep into their half, seemed to be withstanding the pressure. A goal for Germany appeared imminent when Jonathan Tah scored with a well-placed header in the 103rd minute, but VAR intervened, disallowing the goal due to a foul on the goalkeeper, a moment that epitomized the day’s frustrations.
As the match reached its climax, there was an expectation that Paraguay would handle their penalties decisively. As the final whistle blew, tension filled the stadium, leading to a collective anticipation for what was to come.
The players joined arms in solidarity, but an uneasy silence followed as Kai Havertz missed the first penalty, delivering a weak shot that was easily saved.
Meanwhile, Paraguay executed their penalties with remarkable composure, as Germany appeared to falter, their players readying themselves for an inevitable exit. Woltemade followed suit with another weak effort that was saved.
There was still time for misses from Antonio Sanabria and Fabián Balbuena, with Neuer briefly regaining his form. However, Tah’s shot sailed well over the bar. Finally, José Canale sealed the victory for Paraguay, delivering the final blow in a tense shootout.
As the Paraguayan team surged onto the pitch, it marked a moment of triumph.
In an encounter like this, the World Cup continues to surprise, producing moments that are both strange and exhilarating. Across the match’s entirety, both teams managed only six shots on target. For much of the time, the game felt like an unyielding sporting challenge, a blend of noise, movement, and frustration. Yet, by the conclusion, it was undeniably epic.
- World Cup 2026
- Germany
- Paraguay
- World Cup
- match reports
