July 26, 2009
VOL 26 NO 30
Advertise here
  • Home
  • News
  • Sport
  • Arts
  • Business
  • Property
  • Magazine
  • Archive
Home News | International | Letters | Editorial & Opinion  
  • CommentComment
  • PrintPrint
  • E-MailE-mail
Vested interests: The lobby groups that will stand in the way of McCarthy's recommendations
Martin Frawley
  • 1
  • 2

1. Unions


An exercise in "fantasy" and "sheer nonsense" was how Siptu leader Jack O'Connor described the report which took several swings at social partnership, one of Colm McCarthy's pet hates.


But the leader of the biggest trade union in the country was more restrained than he had previously been about the electricians' dispute, suggesting a more measured response from the private sector unions.


Not so the public sector unions, where Peter McLoone of Impact threatened strikes if, as the report suggests, public service pay is cut. John Carr of the national teachers union, the INTO, said the report was an attack on education.


If pay is touched, the national strike that was cancelled earlier this year will be back on.


2. Farmers


Farmers got a bit of a hammering from the UCD economist, who recommended the closure of the Rural Environmental Protection Scheme and the termination of the suckler cow scheme as well as severe staff cuts in the department of agriculture and Teagasc.


Within minutes of the report being published, agriculture minister Brendan Smith's state car was attacked by angry farmers in west Cork.


Speaking on RTE radio moments later, IFA president Pádraig Walshe's apology was less than fulsome, suggesting more vociferous protests are on the way.


3. The Elderly


Fresh from their surprisingly effective protest last October over the withdrawal of the automatic right to a medical card for over-70s, which saw the government execute the sharpest of u-turns, the elderly will be back if the government presses ahead with McCarthy's recommendations on the state pension, rural transport and home care services.


Eamon Timmins of Age Action Ireland said McCarthy's report included "some very drastic cuts for older people", adding that it was the government's job to protect its most vulnerable citizens.


4. Students


Students were also targeted, with McCarthy recommending a €70m cut in the €270m student support scheme, and backing the reintroduction of third level fees, proposals that were roundly criticised by the Union of Students in Ireland and the Irish Federation of University Teachers.


While student marches do not have the shock value of protesting pensioners and cannot hurt the economy, they could have a destabilising effect on an already nervy government.


5. The Unemployed


In terms of pure cash, the country's growing band of social welfare recipients are in line for the deepest cuts of all – €1.8bn, or one third of the €5.3bn recommended.


"What is so striking about the recommendations is how much the less well-off in Irish society are being asked to pay for the failings of the Celtic Tiger," said John Stewart of the Irish National Organisation of the Unemployed.


Like students, the INOU's ability to protest is limited. Far more effective as a 'silent' protest will be the grim TV pictures of snaking dole queues in various parts of the country . But the various unemployed action groups, part of the Socialist Workers Party (SWP), will be far more militant."We need an autumn of protest to kick Cowen and his government out," said the SWP on the report.


July 19, 2009

Post a comment

(Required, published)
(Required, not published)
(Optional)

Comments are moderated by our editors, so there may be a delay between submission and publication of your comment. Offensive or abusive comments will not be published. Please note that your IP address (67.202.55.193) will be logged to prevent abuse of this feature. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions

Related Articles

  • Related
  1. The McCarthy era: cuts both ways...
  2. No more Aga Khan cup... and nine other snips you may have missed

Also in News

  • Popular
  • All
  1. The minister, his wife and €126k expenses
  2. O'Driscoll forcibly removed from Kings of Leon gig
  3. Massereene suspect's father was one of 'hooded men'
  4. What Turns Our Catholic Priests Into Monsters
  5. Split Personalities
  6. Dempsey should be sacked says angry FF backbencher
  7. Sinn Féin to decide on future of party
  8. Tribunal like military dictatorship – O'Brien
  9. O'Donoghue travel expenses shameful
  10. Neo-Nazi website 'extremely sinister', says SDLP councillor
  1. Tribunal like military dictatorship – O'Brien
  2. The minister, his wife and €126k expenses
  3. Split Personalities
  4. What Turns Our Catholic Priests Into Monsters
  5. Dempsey should be sacked says angry FF backbencher
  6. Civil Partnership bill and all involved in it a disgrace
  7. Una Mullally - Is it blasphemous to suggest that the Virgin Mary would waste her time appearing on a tree stump in Rathkeale?
  8. Michael Clifford - "Could those at the top not accept a far greater cut, as they were the biggest beneficiaries when the country was run on Bertie-nomics...."
  9. Brown under fire again after by-election rout
  10. Kurds impatient for change
  11. Bord Snip set out to target the poor and public service
  12. Massereene suspect's father was one of 'hooded men'
  13. Neo-Nazi website 'extremely sinister', says SDLP councillor
  14. Smart economy, like Celtic Tiger, makes me sick
  15. Diarmuid Doyle - "A Yes vote has been deemed by the political and media establishment as the only reasonable result; anybody who holds an alternative view is deeply resented"
  16. Silvio's sex life - Why Italy is in the dark
  17. HSE deficit down from €1 billion to €200m in months
  18. Wagner clan holds reins at opera festival
  19. Here's another money-making idea, Mr O'Leary
  20. David Kenny - Airport tax doesn't put me off flying but O'Leary does
  21. Anglo probe team warns sift of bank 'cannot be rushed'
  22. Colm McCarthy wants us to become an English state
  23. America adopts a rubbish idea for a pool
  24. Johann Hari - "Baron Cohen – one of the great satirists of our time – is taking a prejudiced position to its logical conclusion, in order to expose its absurdity"
  25. We must be prepared for swine-flu epidemic
  26. Outcry in US as child is disowned after rape
  27. O'Driscoll forcibly removed from Kings of Leon gig
  28. No complaints about RTÉ having George Lee as guest
  29. Two small children shot by siblings in 24 hours in US
  30. O'Donoghue travel expenses shameful
  31. Croker a city of blinding lights
  32. Dave Hannigan obviously a fan of US right-wing media
  33. Valerie Shanley's Hindsight Week
  34. Swine flu may cause 26,000 extra hospital admissions at peak
  35. Global Eyes...The World Is Changing
  36. Fake doctor 'worked for pope and had Vatican apartment'
  37. Said & Done
  38. A Thousand Words
  39. Sinn Féin to decide on future of party
  40. Chinese minors and porn DVD factory found in garda swoop on Dublin apartment
  41. Learjets, water taxis and Cannes: all in a day's work for John O'Donoghue
  42. Healy-Rae to get new bypass as thanks for supporting government
  43. RTÉ bans the 'N' word in Killarney jarvey story
  44. Bodies of drowned father and son to return to Poland
  45. Greens may stage 'think-in' on Aran
  46. Rachel O'Reilly's mother pens memoir of her life
  47. Ikea to pay for gardaí to combat M50 traffic chaos
  48. RTE's 'Lords of the Ring' thinks outside the boxing
  49. Blooming Nice Party
  50. Tubridy takes his band to 'Late Late' – minus the name
  51. Open up and say ouch: dental work in south costs 35% more
  52. 'Shot in the backside cost me my council seat'
  53. Massive fall in homophobic crime sparks fear of under-reporting
  54. Talks aim to end spat between gardaí and ombudsman
  55. British woman may be forced to give birth in Laos prison
  56. Artist in residence row
  57. State phone bill for prisoners exceeds €1m
  58. 'There is no smoking gun' – O'Brien lashes tribunal
  59. How to (hopefully) have a swine flu-free day
  60. Awareness and preparedness how organisations are coping
  61. Dunner falls victim - first to Celtic Tiger, then to swine flu
  62. AIB 100% mortgage offer for staff sparks market concern
  63. Dublin church leaders moved sex abuse suspects around parishes
  64. Bono's Broadway musical caught in web of setbacks
  65. U2's €5m music fund gift 'a PR exercise', says tax campaigner
  66. Investigation launched after retired garda detective shoots himself in his old station
  67. McGinley suspected of raping a young relative
  68. Pat Kenny 'frightened' by new show
  69. €5m legal costs for Irish universities since 2006
  70. TD slams government's 'outlandish' €11m investment in Derry airport
  71. Gardaí powerless to stop movement of sex traffickers
  72. Air show set to wow the crowds
  73. Croagh Patrick climbers given safety warning
  74. Two lose lives in road accidents
  75. Search continues for missing man
  76. Man killed in pylon shock tragedy
  77. Fisheries chief attacks cut proposal

Share this article

  • del.icio.usdel.icio.us
  • diggdigg
  • FacebookFacebook
  • GoogleGoogle

Search



  • Note: search is case-sensitive
  • Advanced Search

This issue 5 years ago

  1. ‘Sexist’ banker to apologise for joke
  2. Bush declares war on RTE
  3. Traffic chaos in Belfast as protesters block main roads
  4. Bush gives commitment to peace process
  5. No trouble at Shannon airport protest

RSS Feeds

RSS Feeds

Subscribe to The Sunday Tribune’s RSS feeds. Learn more.

  • Latest Articles
  • News, Business, Sport or Arts

Advertise here
Click to create
  • Contact us
  • |
  • Terms & Conditions
  • |
  • Copyright Notice
Website by Maithú™
Searching